Skip to content
Joe Bellinger

Web Design

Website vs Social Media: What Actually Gets Local Businesses More Customers?

Social media is free and easy, so do you even need a website? Here's an honest breakdown.

Joe Bellinger

Updated · 4 min read

Hand creating a new Instagram post on a phone

Quick answer

You need both, but they do different jobs. Social media keeps you visible to people who already follow you. A website gets you found by people searching for what you do, builds trust, and turns visitors into enquiries. If you can only invest in one properly, the website is the foundation.

A lot of local businesses run entirely off an Instagram or Facebook page, and honestly, it can work, up to a point. So it's a fair question: if social media is free and you're already getting likes and messages there, do you actually need a website too?

I design both websites and social media content for businesses, so I see what each one is good at. Here's an honest breakdown.

What social media does well

It's quick to set up, it's free, and a good post can put you in front of new people without much extra effort. For visual businesses (trades with before-and-after photos, cafés, salons, detailers) it's a brilliant way to show off recent work and build a following.

It's also great for staying in touch with past customers. Someone who followed you after a job sees your posts for months afterwards, which keeps you front of mind for the next job and the next recommendation.

Where social media falls short

You don’t own it

Your page lives on someone else's platform. An algorithm change can cut your reach overnight, an account can get restricted, and audiences drift to new apps. Everything you've built there can shrink without warning.

People scroll, they don’t search

Social media is built for browsing, not searching. When someone needs a service, they don't open Instagram and hope; they type “[service] near me” into Google. Social profiles rarely show up for those searches, so you miss the people who are actively looking to hire someone right now.

Posts disappear

A great post gets a burst of attention and then gets buried. Your best work, your reviews and your service details are scattered across months of posts instead of organised in one place.

The trust question

Plenty of customers still expect a proper business to have a website. When they can't find one, it quietly raises questions, even if your social presence is strong.

What a website gives you that social can’t

  • It shows up on Google, where most people go when they’re ready to hire.
  • You own it completely. No algorithm, no platform risk, no one else’s rules.
  • It works around the clock, taking enquiries while you’re asleep or on a job.
  • It organises everything in one place: services, areas, prices if you show them, reviews, photos and contact details.
  • It converts. A good site is designed to turn a visitor into a call or an enquiry, with a clear path from first impression to “get a quote”.

Search vs scroll: different stages of the same customer

The simplest way to think about it: social media reaches people before they need you, and your website wins them when they do. Someone might see your posts for months, then search for you by name when their roof starts leaking. If what they find is a clear, trustworthy website with an easy way to get in touch, that's the job won.

How to make them work together

  • Put your website link in every bio and pin a post that points to it.
  • Link posts about a specific service to that service’s page on your site.
  • Show your best social content, like reviews and before-and-afters, on your website too.
  • Keep your branding consistent across both, so people recognise you instantly.

That last point matters more than people think. When your posts, ads and website all look like they belong together, the whole business looks more established. You can see an example in the Leads Everyday ad campaigns I designed, which use one consistent look across dozens of posts and trades.

If you can only do one properly, which comes first?

For most local businesses, the website. It's the foundation that everything else points to: social posts, Google Business Profile, directory listings, flyers and van signage. Social media works much harder when there's a proper website behind it to send people to.

If you're doing well on social but have no website backing it up, that's usually the easiest upgrade you can make. Have a look at how I can help, or read whether trade businesses still need a website if you're in the trades.

And if you'd like your social content and website designed to match, get in touch for a free quote.

Frequently asked questions.

Can a small business survive on social media alone?

Some do, especially very visual businesses with a loyal local following. But relying only on social media means you're invisible to most people searching on Google, and exposed to algorithm changes you can't control. A website removes both risks.

Does social media help my Google rankings?

Not directly. Likes and shares aren't a ranking factor. Social media helps indirectly by driving people to your website and getting your business name out there, which can lead to more searches for you by name.

Should my website and social media look the same?

They should share the same branding: logo, colours, fonts and tone of voice. Consistency makes your business recognisable and more trustworthy wherever people come across it.

Do you design social media content as well as websites?

Yes. I design social posts, carousels and ad campaigns, and editable template packs if you want to create your own on-brand posts.

All posts

Keep reading.

Get a free quote